Leadership under pressure is easier to see in a story, so let me introduce a fictional CEO named Marcus. He is not a client. He is made up to show how a pattern can build. Marcus leads a company of about 150 people, and this year revenue has come in below forecast. Cash needs closer watching, and his board wants answers. He starts reviewing decisions his VPs used to make on their own, beginning with hiring requests and vendor commitments, and each review feels consequential because the stakes are real.
Within a few weeks, approvals that used to take a day take a week. His VPs start sending decisions upward before they have finished thinking them through, since they expect Marcus to reopen them anyway. More lands on his desk, so he works longer hours, feels the pressure climb, and naturally reviews even more. Marcus believes he is staying close to the business. His team believes they have lost the authority to decide.
What Pressure Does to the Thinking Brain
Amy Arnsten is a neuroscientist at Yale who has studied stress and the brain for years. In a 2009 review in Nature Reviews Neuroscience, she explained that the front of the brain, called the prefrontal cortex, handles planning, weighing options, and deciding what to pay attention to. It is also the part of the brain most sensitive to stress. Even fairly mild stress, when it feels out of our control, can quickly weaken it. At the same time, parts of the brain that drive fast emotional reactions can work better. In a 2015 review, Arnsten described the shift as a “flip from reflective to reflexive brain state.” Put simply, under stress the brain moves from thinking things through to reacting.
Two abilities that matter a great deal for leaders are impaired. One is holding several options in mind at once, which scientists call working memory. The other is steering where your attention goes instead of letting it be pulled toward the nearest worry. Arnsten’s review names both among the abilities that stress impairs.
Think about it this way. In heavy fog, a driver can see the stretch of road directly ahead with sharp attention but loses the wider view of the approaching exit and the car coming from the side. Pressure can do something similar to a leader’s thinking. The immediate challenge gets nearly all of the attention, and the wider view of the organization gets harder to hold.
A caution is worth making here. Much of this research comes from animal studies, and it was not written about executives. Connecting it to a CEO’s workday is my interpretation, and the research did not test it.
How Leadership Under Pressure Looked From Inside and Outside
Now go back to Marcus. With less room to hold several options at once, he reached for the nearest thing that felt controllable: reviewing his VPs’ decisions. His patience dropped too, because a slower, more deliberate answer required the very ability stress had weakened. From the inside, none of this felt like narrowing. It felt like focus.
From the outside, it looked different. Decision ownership had moved upward without anyone saying so, and his VPs no longer knew which decisions were still theirs. Nobody had said what triggered a review or how long it would take, and capable people had learned that waiting was safer than deciding. Slow approvals were the visible symptom, and the root cause was a change in who decides that no one had named.
Protecting Judgment in Leadership Under Pressure
One evening, a VP named Elena told Marcus she was no longer sure which decisions were hers. That conversation showed him the pattern. He sat down with his CFO and wrote out the options for a large vendor contract on paper, which showed him how many choices he had been carrying in his head at once. Then he listed every decision he had reviewed in the past month and sorted them by cost and reversibility. A multi-year contract and a layoff plan were hard to undo and deserved his attention, while the rest were routine decisions he could correct if they turned out to be wrong.
Marcus set thresholds and shared them with his leadership team. Anything over a certain amount, or anything hard to reverse, came to him, and everything else belonged to his VPs, who would decide within two days. He also asked his CFO to tell him whenever his involvement started to look like a reflex. Approvals sped up, and Marcus had room to think about the business’s larger risks again.
Marcus is fictional, and the steps he took are real choices any leader can make. They work because they take load off the part of the brain that stress weakens. Writing options down means they do not have to live in your head, and deciding ahead of time what comes to you means you are not making that call when your attention is at its narrowest.
The Friction Point
When pressure rises, the brain can shift from thinking things through to reacting, and the organization adapts to the leader’s reactions without being told why. The leader feels a sense of focus and responsibility. The team feels tighter control and less room to decide. Friction builds in the gap between those two experiences and stays there until someone names it.
Two Moves This Week
01. Write down your next hard decision before you make it.
Pick a decision you are facing this week and put the options, the constraints, and what would change your mind on paper. This takes the load off working memory and shows you whether you are weighing several options or only the nearest one.
02. Set your review thresholds and name one check.
Decide which decisions come to you and which don’t, tell your leadership team, and ask one trusted person to flag when your involvement looks like reflex. Do this now, while your attention is broad, because it is much harder to do in the middle of a hard week.
The science cannot tell you what pressure does to your own attention, which is why it helps to ask the people around you what they notice. When pressure rises, what changes first in how you lead?
If it would help to talk through how this shows up in your leadership team, I’d welcome that conversation. You can book a strategy call at nexttonunn.com/strategy-call.
The friction is where growth lives.
Amy K. Nunn is a leadership strategist and founder of Next to Nunn. She works with CEOs and leadership teams to align their people, communication, and systems.
Sources
Arnsten, A. F. T. (2009). Stress signalling pathways that impair prefrontal cortex structure and function. Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 10(6), 410–422. https://doi.org/10.1038/nrn2648
Arnsten, A. F. T. (2015). Stress weakens prefrontal networks: molecular insults to higher cognition. Nature Neuroscience, 18(10), 1376–1385. https://doi.org/10.1038/nn.4087
Keep Reading
Last week: Your Brain Is Looking for Patterns. Also see Building an AI-Ready Organization or browse all editions.
Ready to work through the friction in your organization?
Book a Strategy Call