Edition 36: Your Brain is Looking for Patterns.

Edition No. 36  |  November 3, 2026
The Leadership Friction  |  Amy K. Nunn
Your Brain Is Looking for Patterns
Experience helps leaders spot patterns. It can also shape what they find.

One of the advantages of having years of leadership experience is that you have seen enough to recognize when something looks familiar. You have worked with executives who resist accountability, leaders who struggle to make decisions, and people who create unnecessary friction within a team. Those experiences teach you what to watch for, and over time, you become quicker at recognizing behaviors that have caused difficulties before.

But recognizing a familiar behavior and understanding what is causing it are two different things. When we believe we already know what someone’s behavior means, that conclusion begins influencing how we communicate with them, which opportunities we give them, and how we respond when they challenge our thinking. Eventually, our own responses may contribute to the very behavior we believed we recognized in the first place.

Consider a CEO who previously worked with an executive who frequently challenged decisions, undermined colleagues, and made it difficult for the leadership team to move forward. The experience was costly, and the CEO learned to recognize behaviors that seemed to signal resistance or a lack of alignment. Years later, another executive begins raising concerns during leadership meetings. The questions sound familiar, and the CEO starts wondering whether the same difficulties are developing again.

There is one significant difference. This executive is raising legitimate concerns about decisions that have not been fully examined. The CEO, however, has already begun interpreting the questions as resistance. Over time, the CEO becomes less receptive to that executive’s input, occasionally moves conversations forward without inviting their perspective, and begins treating their questions as obstacles rather than information worth considering. The executive notices the change and becomes more guarded or frustrated, and the CEO reads that as further evidence that the original concern was justified. The CEO believes experience is identifying a familiar concern, while the executive finds it harder to contribute to decisions.

When Experience Influences What We See

Our minds use previous experiences to make sense of new situations. When something looks familiar, we draw on what we already know rather than examining every detail as though we are encountering it for the first time. That ability is useful, particularly for executives who regularly make decisions with incomplete information and limited time.

In 1974, psychologists Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman published research on how people make judgments under uncertainty. They identified several mental shortcuts, including representativeness, which involves judging something partly by how closely it resembles a familiar example or category. These shortcuts are efficient, but they can lead to predictable errors when the resemblance receives more weight than other relevant information.

The original research examined human judgment rather than executive-team dynamics, but the principle applies to leadership. When someone reminds us of a difficult person from our past, we may interpret their behavior through that experience, noticing similarities while overlooking differences that would lead us to a different conclusion.

In my book Dirty Lenses: A Practical Guide to Clarify Your Vision, I wrote:

“Our past experiences can lead to different interpretations of the same event.”

I’ve thought about that quite a bit in the context of executive leadership. Two executives can sit through the same meeting, hear the same questions, and leave with entirely different interpretations of what happened. One may see a colleague who is raising legitimate concerns, while another sees someone who is being difficult or resisting direction. Their interpretation may have as much to do with what they’ve experienced previously as it does with what actually happened in the room.

That is why I believe executives need to be willing to examine the lenses through which they view the people they lead. Our experiences are valuable, but they can also influence what we notice, what we overlook, and the meaning we attach to someone’s behavior.

There is also an important distinction between having experience and knowing when to trust your interpretation of it. In 2009, Daniel Kahneman and Gary Klein examined the conditions under which professional intuition is more likely to be reliable, emphasizing environments with recognizable patterns and opportunities for meaningful feedback. Simply feeling confident in an intuitive judgment does not establish that the judgment is accurate.

That distinction matters when evaluating people. Leadership behavior is influenced by circumstances, relationships, organizational expectations, and the authority someone has been given. An executive may recognize a behavior accurately but still misunderstand why it is happening. The more significant the decision, the more important it becomes to examine the evidence behind that interpretation.

How One Executive’s Judgment Can Influence an Entire Team

In the earlier example, the CEO’s concern about the questioning executive does not remain a private thought. It begins affecting whose perspective is invited into conversations, how disagreements are received, and whether the executive feels able to raise concerns without being labeled difficult.

Other members of the leadership team may begin noticing that the CEO is less receptive to this person’s input. Some may stop involving the executive in early discussions because they expect the conversation to become uncomfortable. Others may begin interpreting the person’s questions as resistance because that appears to be how the CEO views them. Eventually, a reputation can develop around someone without the team having a shared understanding of what is actually happening.

This can become an organizational issue because executive teams depend on people being willing to examine decisions, raise concerns, and disagree when necessary. That does not mean every disagreement is constructive or that executives should be allowed to challenge decisions indefinitely. There is a difference between someone who raises a concern to improve a decision and someone who repeatedly undermines decisions after the team has committed to them. The responsibility of the CEO is to understand which behavior is occurring rather than assuming the two are interchangeable.

A fixed judgment can also influence positive assessments. A CEO may continue viewing an executive as highly capable because that person performed exceptionally well several years ago, even though the organization’s needs have changed. In that situation, previous success may prevent the CEO from recognizing where the leader now needs development or where the role has grown beyond their current capabilities.

These situations affect more than individual relationships. They influence hiring, succession planning, leadership development, decision quality, and the willingness of executives to contribute perspectives that may be unpopular but necessary. When an interpretation becomes widely accepted without being examined, the organization can begin making decisions around an assumption rather than the current evidence.

The Friction Point

Executives have to make judgments, often without having all the information they would prefer. The friction begins when those judgments become so settled that they influence the conditions around a person and then seem to confirm themselves.

When I look at situations like these, I want to understand more than whether someone’s behavior is causing frustration. I want to know what has actually been observed, what meaning has been attached to it, and whether the executive’s response has changed how that person operates within the organization.

Sometimes the concern is rooted in an individual’s behavior or capability. Other times, unclear expectations, inconsistent communication, or the way the leadership team makes decisions may be contributing to what is happening. Often, there is some combination of People, Communication, and Systems that needs to be examined before deciding what should change.

On the Systems side, I want to know whether anything in how decisions get made asks for the evidence behind an assessment of a colleague, and whether anyone else in the room is positioned to say what the executive actually said. Without those checks, a CEO’s read can become the working fact, and one leader’s interpretation can become the team’s shared view.

Experience should help us recognize when something deserves attention. It should also help us know when we need to ask a few more questions before deciding what it means.

Two Moves This Week

1. Reconsider one judgment you have made about another leader.

Think about someone on your executive or senior leadership team whom you have developed a strong opinion about, either positive or negative. Consider the experiences that led you to that conclusion and whether they still accurately reflect the person’s current behavior. Have you noticed evidence that challenges your opinion, or have you primarily been paying attention to what confirms it? You may still arrive at the same conclusion, but it is worth knowing that you have examined it rather than simply carried it forward.

2. Consider how your interpretation may be influencing your response.

Think about how you communicate with this person, the responsibility you give them, and how you respond when they question a decision or approach something differently than you would. Have your expectations or reactions changed because of what you believe about them? If so, consider whether those changes are helping address a legitimate concern or contributing to the behavior that frustrates you.

Executive experience is valuable, and the ability to recognize patterns can help leaders address concerns before they become more serious. But there are times when our confidence in what we have seen before prevents us from fully examining what is happening now. A familiar pattern is a reason to pay attention, not necessarily a reason to stop investigating.

What have you decided is true about someone that you have not examined recently?

The friction is where growth lives.

Amy K. Nunn signature

Leadership Strategist | Next to Nunn

If this brought a particular leadership situation to mind, consider sharing it with your executive team and discussing how previous experiences may be influencing current judgments.

At Next to Nunn, we work with owners, CEOs, and leadership teams to identify the People, Communication, and Systems behind recurring organizational friction and determine what needs to be addressed. Book a strategy call.

Related Editions

Your Emotions Are Part of the Business looks at how a leader’s reaction to bad news shapes what a team feels safe telling them.

Being Needed Isn’t the Same as Leading Well separates access from dependence when a CEO helps with decisions.

Research and Book References

Tversky, A., & Kahneman, D. (1974). Judgment under uncertainty: Heuristics and biases. Science, 185(4157), 1124–1131. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.185.4157.1124

Kahneman, D., & Klein, G. (2009). Conditions for intuitive expertise: A failure to disagree. American Psychologist, 64(6), 515–526. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0016755

Nunn, Amy K. (2023). Dirty Lenses: A Practical Guide to Clarify Your Vision. Chapter 2, page 16.

Scroll to Top