Edition 3: Talent in the Wrong Seat

Edition No. 3  |  November 3, 2026
Between the Work and the People  |  Erinn Gomillion, Leadership Development Partner

Talent in the Wrong Seat

A title can put someone in the seat. It can't tell them what the seat requires.

This edition looks at what happens when a strong performer is promoted into a seat that no one ever described, and the three places to look before you decide the person is the problem.

The Scenario

He was one of the first people in the office and the last to leave every day, working 10- to 11-hour days Monday through Friday, often online on weekends too. When I asked why, he told me it was to stay on top of escalations, which meant he stayed available day and night.

But escalations were only part of his job. He supervised a large team of agents with enormous responsibility but zero oversight: no performance metrics, no one monitoring attendance, and no way to explain their impact to the business. Being new to the department, I told my director I wanted to do more observations to fully understand the team before making any recommendations about how it was run.

During this time, I got to know him and his team. He genuinely loved solving problems, and he was one of the most technically knowledgeable people in the department. Although he didn't enjoy working long hours, he really did enjoy the work. The more we worked together, the clearer it became to me that the way he was leading, or not leading, wasn't entirely his fault.

One day, I asked him why he took the supervisor role. He said it was because he knew how to solve customer issues better than most and wanted to keep helping customers. Managing or developing people wasn't even on his radar. I then asked him, "Have you ever thought about how many more customers you could help if you taught all the agents on your team to handle interactions the way you do?" The idea hadn't occurred to him.

That conversation opened the door to reframe his job. Since no one had ever told him that coaching and developing his team was his actual job as a supervisor, he never considered his impact beyond the daily work of escalations. I explained that he had the title of supervisor, but he was still doing the work of the people he was supposed to lead. I then asked him how he was going to find time to lead his team and still do the work the way he wanted to, and that's when it clicked for him. He realized it was impossible. This wasn't a gap he could close by working harder. This was great talent, just in the wrong seat.

Fast forward a few years. Together we rebuilt the team with new expectations. We hired another supervisor, built real schedules, created step-by-step guides, and put an escalation plan in place. Then we implemented consistent coaching, team meetings, and annual performance evaluations. When he began coaching his agents, I sat in on those sessions with him. This was all a big change for him, and he struggled a lot, but he stayed through every change. Eventually he moved into a role built around what he was good at: solving tough technical challenges with back-end systems. I wasn't surprised or hurt by this in the least. I count it as one of my biggest wins. I helped create a structure that will last longer than both of us, showed him what leading people involves, and helped him move into the position he was meant to be in.

Why Strong Performers End Up in the Wrong Seat

Nobody did anything wrong on purpose. Strong performers get promoted because they are good at the work, and we all treat the promotion as proof they will be good at what comes next. The work in the new seat is different. It asks them to teach, review, and follow up instead of just solving. When nobody names that difference, the person keeps doing what made them successful, and the seat stays empty.

What Is Yours to Own

When someone is struggling in a role, it's tempting to look only at the person. Before you decide, look at three places.

People. Is this person in the right seat, doing work they are good at and want to do? He knew the work better than almost anyone. That tells you a lot about his skill and very little about whether he wanted to spend his days developing his agents.

Communication. Has anyone said, out loud, what the seat requires? In his case, the title said supervisor, and what he did all day stayed the same. If you can't remember a conversation where the expectation was stated in plain words, assume it wasn't heard.

Systems. What came with the title? A schedule that leaves room for the job, goals, a way to see how the team is doing, and someone whose job is to develop the new leader instead of only checking their output. His seat came with none of it. A quick test: if you took the title away, what would this person be measured on? If you can't answer that, they probably can't either. In a 2023 survey of more than 4,500 UK workers and managers, the Chartered Management Institute, a UK professional body for managers, found that 82% of workers entering management positions have not had any formal management and leadership training. He was not an exception. He was the norm.

You can have the right person and still not get the result if nobody built anything around them. And sometimes, as it was here, one question shows you what a person needs, and the structure gets built after.

What to Say When You Name the Seat

When you put someone into a new role, or realize no one ever described the one they're in, try saying it plainly:

"Here is what this seat requires that your last one didn't."

"Here is what done looks like in this role, and here is what I'd like you to stop doing."

"Tell me in your own words what you think the job is, so we can see where we match and where we don't."

Say it once, then put it in writing, then ask what they need from you to do it. The point isn't a longer job description. It's making sure the two of you are describing the same job.

If you're the one in the seat, you may feel it before you can name it: long days, a full inbox, and a sense that you're working hard at something that isn't quite the job. That feeling is information. Ask your manager what done looks like. You don't have to wait to be told.

The Leadership Check

What part of your old job are you still doing, and what part of this one is still waiting for you to do?

Two Moves for This Week

Ask for their version of the job. Pick one newer or recently promoted leader. Ask them to tell you, in their own words, what they think their job is beyond the daily work. Listen to the whole answer before you correct anything. Where it differs from yours, that is where the expectation was never set.

If you're the one in the seat, ask for yours. Ask your manager: "What does done look like in this role, and what should I stop doing?" You don't have to wait for someone to volunteer the answer.

Closing

A title is permission to sit in the seat. Someone has to say what the seat requires and build it into the week. That isn't an argument for keeping people out of leadership. It's an argument for telling them what the seat asks, so they can choose to take it or leave it with the full picture. Sometimes you find it was said, it was built, and the person still isn't the right fit. Sometimes, like the supervisor I worked with, you find someone who was in the wrong seat the whole time, and nobody had asked. If you're working out what a role should ask of someone on your team, or of you, send me a message and tell me which seat you're trying to define.

At Next to Nunn, I help leaders to build strong teams and step fully into their leadership role.

To get Between the Work and the People as each edition comes out, subscribe here: https://api.leadconnectorhq.com/widget/form/vjbvXlHnVAEJakPZDnun

Erinn Gomillion's signature
Stay Connected

Between the Work and the People is published by Next to Nunn. Browse every past edition, or learn more about Erinn and the leadership development work she does with managers, directors, and senior leaders.

Meet Erinn Explore Leadership Coaching
About the Author

Erinn Gomillion
Leadership Development Partner
Next to Nunn

Erinn helps leaders build strong teams and step fully into their leadership role.

Meet Erinn
Scroll to Top